Weight talk

Does Fat-Shaming Make Anyone Lose Weight? What the Studies Found

Fat-shaming and weight stigma explained, plus what studies in the US, England and China found about shaming, weight gain and avoiding exercise.

Reviewed by Kumar Abhishek, Lead Coach Published 7 min read

Two adults discuss an open research book in a supportive outdoor setting.

In short

  • Fat-shaming means mocking or blaming someone for their weight.
  • The studies we read do not show that it helps.
  • Two long-running studies, in the US and in England, linked reporting weight discrimination to weight gain or becoming obese later.
  • They are observational, so they show an association, not cause.
  • Other work links stigma to avoiding exercise.
  • We found no evidence that shaming helps.

If you have been called names about your weight, or you love someone who has, you may be wondering whether the teasing does any good. Short answer from the research we read: we found no study showing that shaming helps, and several that link it to the opposite. This post gives the meanings first, then each study with its numbers and its limits.

What is fat-shaming, and what is weight stigma?

Three related terms. Fat-shaming: Mocking or blaming someone for their weight or size. Weight stigma: Negative attitudes and unfair treatment based on weight. Body shaming: Mocking bodies of any size or shape. A remark can be hurtful even when someone describes it as a joke.
The terms overlap, but weight stigma includes unfair treatment beyond spoken comments.

Fat-shaming is mocking, blaming or embarrassing someone because of their weight or body size. It can be a joke at a wedding, a comment about your plate, or a stranger's look at the gym. In India it often sounds like "Moti ho gayi ho" ("you have become fat") or "Tond nikal aayi" ("your belly has come out"), said by people who mean well or who do not.

Weight stigma is the wider idea: negative attitudes and unfair treatment aimed at people because of their weight. The studies below call the unfair treatment weight discrimination. Body shaming is the broader phrase for mocking any body, whether larger, thinner, shorter or otherwise. If you are searching for what these words mean, that is all of it. The harder question is whether the behaviour works.

What did the studies find about shaming and weight?

An open research book, notes and magnifying glass represent examining the evidence.
Read what the studies measured and their limits, rather than assuming shame motivates change.

Here are the main papers, read from their published abstracts. All the weight-change studies are observational: researchers followed people and recorded what happened, they did not assign shaming to one group and not to another (which would be unethical). So they show an association. They cannot prove that discrimination caused the weight change.

Studies on weight discrimination, weight change and exercise
StudyWho and how manyWhat it found
Sutin and Terracciano, PLoS ONE, 20136,157 adults in the Health and Retirement Study, USA; weight measured in 2006 and 2010People who reported weight discrimination had about 2.5 times the odds of becoming obese by follow-up (OR 2.54, 95% CI 1.58–4.08), and those already obese had about 3 times the odds of staying obese (OR 3.20, 95% CI 2.06–4.97)
Jackson, Beeken and Wardle, Obesity, 20142,944 adults aged 50 and over, English Longitudinal Study of Ageing; weight measured in 2008–09 and 2012–13Reported discrimination went with relative gains of 1.66 kg in weight and 1.12 cm in waist, and higher odds of becoming obese (OR 6.67, 95% CI 1.85–24.04). Odds of remaining obese did not differ (OR 1.09, 95% CI 0.46–2.59)
Tomiyama and colleagues, BMC Medicine, 2018An opinion article reviewing evidence, not a new studySays weight stigma is harmful to health beyond body mass index, is prospectively related to higher mortality and other chronic conditions, and likely drives weight gain
Rubino and colleagues, Nature Medicine, 2020A multidisciplinary group of international experts using a modified Delphi processReviewed the evidence and said weight stigma can cause physical and psychological harm and is unacceptable; recommends education to eliminate weight bias
Li and colleagues, Frontiers in Psychology, 20251,397 Chinese university students aged 17–25, one-time surveyHigher weight stigma was linked to higher internalised stigma, then social anxiety, then more motivation to avoid exercise

Read the first two rows carefully. In the US study, the result held after the authors accounted for age, sex, ethnicity, education and starting BMI, and it did not appear for other kinds of discrimination such as sex or race. In the English study the confidence interval for becoming obese is very wide (1.85 to 24.04), so the exact size of that figure is uncertain. Both groups of authors concluded that discrimination does not motivate weight loss, and the English authors wrote that it promotes weight gain. That is their interpretation of an association.

What these studies cannot tell you

Both weight studies were done in the US and England (the English one in people aged 50 or more), and discrimination was reported by the participants themselves. We did not find a study of this kind in India among the papers we read. Someone gaining weight may also be more likely to be mocked, so cause and effect could run either way, though the authors adjusted for starting weight to address this.

Why might shaming backfire?

Avoiding a gym can mean finding another way. Painful experiences: Interview participants described fear of stigma. Avoiding some settings: Some changed the places or times they exercised. Continuing elsewhere: Some still moved in spaces such as home. This comes from 30 interviews; it cannot establish what happens to everyone.
Avoiding an uncomfortable gym does not necessarily mean avoiding all movement.

We can only report the explanations the papers give, and they are cautious. Tomiyama and colleagues write that stigma raises obesity risk "through multiple obesogenic pathways" and that it is especially harmful in healthcare, where they describe patients with higher weight receiving poorer care and having worse outcomes. Rubino and colleagues say affected people are less likely to receive adequate care.

On exercise, the Chinese student study found a chain: stigma was associated with believing the mockery yourself (internalised stigma), which was associated with social anxiety, which was associated with wanting to avoid exercise. The authors note it was a cross-sectional survey, which rules out conclusions about cause, and that few participants had a high BMI.

A 2021 interview study in BMC Public Health spoke to 30 adults with obesity (average BMI 40.64). Participants described staying out of some sport and exercise settings because of painful experiences and fear of stigma. Importantly, the authors found that not all of this self-exclusion meant less exercise: some people avoided certain places or times, or chose "safe" spaces such as home, and still exercised. Thirty interviews cannot be generalised, but they show that avoiding a gym is not the same as avoiding movement.

What helps instead?

Conversation bubbles and a heart represent listening and practical support.
Practical support respects the person and their choices.

The papers we read do not offer a magic fix, and we will not invent one. They do point in a few directions.

  • Change the people who stigmatise, not the person targeted. Tomiyama and colleagues say the most effective and ethical approaches aim at the behaviour and attitudes of those who stigmatise. If a relative keeps commenting, see what to say when relatives comment on your weight.
  • Better training for health professionals. Both Tomiyama and Rubino call for education about weight bias in healthcare.
  • Reduce internalised stigma and social anxiety. The Chinese student study recommends this to help people overcome avoiding exercise. A doctor or mental health professional is the right person for that.
  • Make movement feel safe. In the interview study, some people kept exercising by choosing settings where they felt safe, including home.

If you are the one who wants to help someone you love, the research says to be careful with pressure. We cover the words to use in how to talk about someone's weight.

If the comments are affecting your mood or eating

Being shamed can weigh on your mind. If you feel low for weeks, avoid eating, or eat in ways that scare you, please speak to a doctor or a mental health professional. This post is general information, not medical advice.

What does this look like in India?

Keep two kinds of evidence separate. Body-size surveys: NFHS reports population weight categories. Stigma studies: The cited research comes from the US, England and China. The gap: Neither tells us how often Indian families make weight jokes. Population weight figures are not measurements of teasing or an individual’s health.
The article’s India context does not turn overseas stigma findings into Indian statistics.

India's National Family Health Survey-5 (2019–21) is the usual source for national numbers. As reported by Down To Earth, 24% of women were overweight or obese in NFHS-5, up from 20.6% in NFHS-4 (2015–16), and 22.9% of men, up from 18.9%. The article defines this as a BMI of 25 or more. We could not open the official fact sheet, so please check the figures on the survey's own site before quoting them.

What those figures mean is simple: a large number of people live in larger bodies, so many of them also hear the jokes. The studies above come from the US, England and China, so we do not claim they measure Indian families.

Do you have to want to lose weight?

Your goal is your choice. Want to train?: Choose what you would like to improve. Want private support?: A coach can work with your current abilities. Do not want weight loss?: That is your decision too. Being teased is not a reason you must start losing weight.
Training and support can follow your preferences, rather than someone else’s comments.

No. Some readers want to change their weight, and some do not. Both are fine, and being teased is not a reason to start. If you do want to train, a live coach on a video call means nobody else is watching, and the coach works with the body you have today. Our guide for online personal training for overweight beginners covers what that looks like.

Wondering about pace? See how long it takes to see results from the gym, and if the scale stalls, not losing weight in a calorie deficit.

When is World Obesity Day?

The organiser's About page gives the 2026 World Obesity Day as 4 March. We could not find a published date for 2027 (4 March 2027 falls on a Thursday), so please check worldobesityday.org for the date and what is planned.

Sources

  1. Perceived weight discrimination and obesity, PLoS ONE (via PubMed)
  2. Perceived weight discrimination and changes in weight, waist circumference, and weight status, Obesity (via PubMed)
  3. How and why weight stigma drives the obesity 'epidemic' and harms health, BMC Medicine (via PubMed)
  4. Joint international consensus statement for ending stigma of obesity, Nature Medicine (via PubMed)
  5. Associations between weight stigma and exercise avoidance motivation among college students, Frontiers in Psychology (via PubMed)
  6. Weight stigma experiences and self-exclusion from sport and exercise settings among people with obesity, BMC Public Health (via PubMed)
  7. About World Obesity Day, World Obesity Day, World Obesity Federation
  8. Obesity increases in India; Haryana, Karnataka among worst performers: NFHS-5, Down To Earth

Written by the MakeMyFitness team from the sources above and reviewed by Kumar Abhishek, our lead coach (Diploma in Personal Training, K11 School of Fitness Sciences). First published , last updated . How we write and check our guides: editorial policy. This is general fitness information, not medical advice: see the medical disclaimer.

In a dining area with a table and chair, an athlete asks a question and a home coach responds on video.

Questions people ask

About does Fat-Shaming Make Anyone Lose Weight? What the Studies Found.

  • Fat-shaming means mocking, blaming or embarrassing someone because of their weight or body size. It is one form of weight stigma, which is the wider term for negative attitudes and unfair treatment because of weight.

Still have a question?Leave your number in the booking form and we'll call you.

Book a session

Your first rep starts here.

We’ll call to confirm your coach, talk through your goals and send you a private video link.

In a home office with a work desk and bookshelf, choose a date, then receive confirmation for a live home workout.
  • Live on video, from anywhere
  • Coach matched to your goals
  • No long-term contracts

Step 1 of 4

What kind of training are you after?

1:1 · Live video · At home. Live one-on-one video classes in your living room, built around the space and equipment you have, even if that's just a mat.

In a living room with a sofa and floor lamp, an athlete is welcomed into live home training.

Your Fitness.
Your Way.

Stop planning to start. Book your first session today.

Book a session